Top 10 Patreon Alternatives I Personally Tested in 2025

Top 10 Patreon Alternatives I Personally Tested in 2025

Patreon is one of the most widely known platforms for creators to build communities of fans and monetize their paywalled content. It allows fans to subscribe to creator-customized tiers of monthly memberships in return for exclusive content, chats, early access to videos, and other perks.

Patreon gained its initial popularity thanks to YouTubers after the infamous Adpocalypses of the twenty-teens, and strict video demonetization policies that made it very difficult to predict one’s payout. However, many creators struggle to grow past a certain point with Patreon, which makes them seek Patreon alternatives.

Luckily, there are plenty of Patreon competitors that cater to full-time creators of all specializations and address all of the issues they might face with this popular membership platform.

How did I test and review Patreon alternatives

While Patreon can be an option for a beginner creator, it’s limited and quickly outlives its usefulness for creators with a large following. Among the most common problems creators name stagnant growth, high fees, and “algorithm burnout” from the weekly necessity to come up with new exclusive content to keep patrons interested. 

The paradox is that all of these downsides stem from what makes Patreon attractive to newbie creators initially:

  • High fees. The lack of fixed monthly fees is attractive: you only pay a 10% commission when you start earning. However, as revenue grows, these cuts grow to a hefty sum that does not translate into more features or convenience for the creator.
  • Algorithm burnout. Starting Patreon is quick and stress-free, but with minimal customization, you can’t create an exclusive experience for your audience and make your content evergreen with playlists, ratings, and personalized recommendations. Instead, Patreon’s chronological feed feels like a treadmill.
  • Limited appeal. Often, fans cannot afford to pay monthly subscriptions to all their favorite authors. Instead, they would rather support them occasionally with tips or by buying a one-off treat (a book or a piece of merch). Patreon doesn’t fully cater to this need.

Keeping it all in mind, I evaluated Patreon alternatives centering creators’ needs: memberships, community interaction, tipping, digital product sales, paid content distribution, and some niche-specific features like livestreaming or publishing.

Some of the platforms on this list are direct Patreon competitors. Others only partially overlap with its features but shine in areas where Patreon falls short – course creation, store-style catalogs, native video hosting, etc.

My goal was to assess how well each platform serves the daily workflow of a specific creator reliant on it as a main source of income, so I nominated Patreon alternatives according to creator types: streamers, musicians, podcasters, etc.

My selection criteria

To compare all these tools meaningfully, I zeroed in on the following:

  • Ease of use (how intuitive signing up, creating a membership or product page, publishing, etc.)
  • Membership features (how flexible custom tiers and adjustable associated perks are)
  • Community tools (DMs, community spaces, discussion groups, and other creator-fan relationship tools)
  • Sales and one-off tips (ability to sell digital downloads, merch, receive one-time donations, pay-what-you-want options, etc.)
  • Marketing tools (email, funnels, landings, SEO, social media integrations, automations)
  • Integrations (native apps vs. APIs, possibility of embeds, etc.)
  • Fees and total cost (entry-level plans and commissions for Patreon free alternatives)
  • Payouts and financial management (payout methods and speeds, currency support, VAT handling, invoicing, etc.)
  • Scalability (how far can creators grow without having to switch platforms again)

My testing process

To review each of the platforms listed here, I followed my usual method:

  1. Signed up for a free plan or a trial period
  2. Set up a simple tier structure
  3. Created paywalled posts or other content drops
  4. Added digital products (where available)
  5. Created and customized available pages (shop, subscriptions, info)
  6. Explored community features and messaging tools
  7. Checked integrations 
  8. Connected payment processors
  9. Published a demo page and viewed it as a supporter

Because live testing requires more time, I based some of my evaluations on my experience in the creator tools industry, publicly available data from the platforms, and verified feedback from long-term users.

Disclaimer: All pricing, features availability, integrations, and trial terms provided here are based on publicly available data and were accurate at the time of writing. Some details may have changed by the time you read this. Always double-check the platform’s website and consult customer support before making your final choice.

Alternatives to Patreon at a glance

Platform

Best for

Features

Pricing

All creators (artists, creators, musicians, writers, etc.)

Full e-commerce solution + subscriptions, no fees, POD, digital delivery, flexibility, donations

From $22/mo

 Writers/bloggers

Newsletter with inbox-first delivery, audience discovery, free to start

Free (10% Substack commission + processing fees)

 Educators/coaches

Course builder, memberships, coaching, website builder

 From $39/month

Free alternative for beginners

One-time tips, memberships, commissions, and shop

 5% transaction fee (0% for donations)

 Bands/Musicians

Branded app, fun club, merch, tickets, music streaming

From $44.99/month 

Podcasters

All-in-one podcast hosting + distribution, premium memberships, digital and physical sales

From $19/month +15% platform fees

Streamers/Creators who want simple support

One-click tips, store, memberships, streaming alerts

5% fee on each transaction

Digital and traditional artists

E-commerce with memberships, licensing tools, PDF stamping

Free: 5% $29/month: 2% $99/month: 0%

Filmmakers/Video creators

Video hosting, memberships, paywalled collections, branded site

Free (5% fees) $15/month Pro

Photographers/digital creators

Simple digital storefront + membership, tax tools, pay-what-you-want pricing

10% + $0.50 per sale (direct) → 30% per sale on Discover Marketplace

1. Sellfy: The best Patreon alternative for creators

Sellfy is a creator-first e-commerce platform that makes it easy for artists, designers, musicians, and other content makers to sell all the digital product staples and get supported by their fans. Minimal setup and no transaction fees from the platform make Sellfy an easy entry-level or great migration choice.

You can sell digital products, subscriptions, print-on-demand merch, or physical goods with more control over pricing, products, and storefront branding than Patreon can ever give. At the same time, Sellfy is just as user-friendly, intuitive, and streamlined as Patreon, but with many more features and creative freedom.Sellfy dashboard

Why I picked Sellfy

Sellfy bridges the gap between barebones membership/community platforms like Patreon and full-blown e-commerce systems like Shopify. 

For creators who want to sell custom products (downloads, subscriptions, merch) instead of just memberships or fan support, Sellfy offers an affordable, low-friction way to launch a fully functional online store and create a branded, unique experience for their fans.

Sellfy themes

Patreon’s model is good for absolute newbies, but Sellfy removes Patreon’s limits and allows you to be flexible and scale up:

  • Instead of ever-growing commissions, you have a fixed monthly payment that doesn’t eat away at your earnings. When you can afford to spend more, you can upgrade your plan and unlock new advanced features.
  • Sellfy gives you full control over the presentation of your content: you can create curated playlists, bundles, courses, and downloadable products that are evergreen, removing the constant pressure to update. You can focus on quality instead of quantity.
  • Unlike on Patreon, where fans often wait until the creator accumulates more paywalled content, subscribe, binge, and cancel, because they cannot afford a monthly subscription to all their favorite artists. On Sellfy, they have an option for a one-off purchase. This flexibility benefits both creators and their fans with varying levels of disposable income.
  • If you aren’t ready to let go of Patreon just yet, you can keep both. Simply integrate your Patreon offerings into your Sellfy store.

Standout features

  • Fully functional e-commerce website with great potential for scaling and customization
  • Easy store setup: especially good for solo creators or small teams who don’t want to tinker with many apps or plugins 
  • Unlimited products across all paid plans (digital downloads, physical, subscriptions/memberships)
  • Zero platform transaction fees 
  • Transparent pricing and clear upgrade path when you hit sales thresholds 
  • Instant payout: you receive funds directly with no platform holding periods
  • Built-in checkout, hosting, delivery of digital assets, and an option to embed “Buy” buttons or a full store on your existing site/blog
  • Built-in print-on-demand service 
  • Marketing automation: discount codes, coupon mechanics, affiliate program (on Business/Premium tiers), upsells, and cart abandonment tools
  • E-mail marketing tool integrated into the platform, so you won’t need a separate app
  • Custom domain support, SSL, mobile-optimized checkout/UX out of the box 

Sellfy

Products you can sell

Digital downloads, subscriptions, access to libraries, services, print-on-demand merch, and other physical products, bundles, and upsells, including “pay what you want” items. 

Integrations

PayPal, Stripe, Google Analytics, Google Merchant Center, Facebook pixel, Twitter Ads, Zapier connectivity, +DIY integrations via webhooks, embeddable checkout/store widgets for blogs and social media.

Pricing 

Starter Plan: Starter ($22 a month)

  • No platform fees
  • Up to $10,000 annual sales cap
  • Unlimited products, digital, physical, subscriptions
  • Unique domain
  • Email marketing
  • Store customization

Best Value Plan: Business ($59 a month)

  • Up to $50,000 annual sales cap
  • Everything from Starter, plus:
  • Enhanced email marketing
  • Advanced marketing tools (product upselling, cart abandonment, affiliate program)
  • Full customization (no “Sellfy” branding)
  • Store design migration

For a creator who wants to sell products rather than rely purely on patronage, Sellfy offers a full storefront, product flexibility, and great marketing tools, remaining lean and creator-friendly. It’s a balance of simplicity, brand control, and cost efficiency, perfect for solo creators and small teams focused on a unique experience for their fans. 

Sellfy is a smart, affordable choice to own your store and brand, combining the best of both worlds: community-building, crowd-funding, and e-commerce.

2. Substack: Best Patreon alternative for writers

Substack is a newsletter-publishing platform designed specifically for authors, bloggers, and journalists who want to monetize their writing through subscriptions and build their readership. Its main feature is a paid newsletter delivered directly to the subscriber’s inbox, fostering more direct and candid relationships between writers and their fans.

Substack dashboard

Why I picked Substack

I chose Substack over other likely Patreon alternatives for writers because it’s a straightforward reader-facing solution. You don’t have to set up a full website and storefront: all its features cater to writers and bloggers and are streamlined for monetizing long-form content.

Standout features

  • Free to start publishing and monetizing your newsletters
  • Customizable monthly and yearly subscription tiers: free tier, paid tier, occasional free + paid mix
  • Content gets delivered directly to every subscriber instead of being buried in their feeds
  • Custom domain support
  • Built-in audience discovery with recommendations 
  • Native social-media-like community and engagement features: notes, comments, discussion threads, reader replies
  • Built-in analytics tools for tracking subscriber growth, open rates, click-through, and revenue
  • Flexible blog-newsletter hybrid that allows writing and scheduling posts and podcasts, and embedding other media

Substack dashboard

Products you can sell

Monthly/yearly subscriptions and free content to grow the audience: newsletters, essays, commentary, updates, serialized writing, podcast episodes, etc. Merch and downloadables are possible, but only via integrations with external services.

Integrations

Stripe, Webflow, Squarespace, YouTube, Spotify, Instagram, Discord, Zapier.

Pricing 

Substack doesn’t offer a subscription model to creators, just as Patreon nowadays: it’s free to start. Instead, you pay:

  • 10% cut of each transaction to Substack
  • -2.9% +$0.30 per transaction in credit card fee to Stripe
  • 0.7% billing fee for recurring subscriptions to Stripe
  • There are also varying fees for non-credit card methods (iDEAL: 80¢, Bancontact: 1.4% + 30¢, Sofort: 1.4% + 30¢, and SEPA Direct: 0.8% + 30¢, capped at $6.00)

Substack is a no-frills writer-friendly environment that puts content front and center. I found it very easy to launch a newsletter, and I liked that social media feel of the platform. However, there’s not much else. If you ever need anything on top of it, Substack stops being easy and accommodating.

Want to explore other newsletter options? Here are some tips on Sellfy’s email marketing possibilities.

3. Podia: Best Patreon alternative for educators

Podia is a user-friendly and simple all-in-one platform centered on educators and creators who primarily sell courses, coaching, digital downloads, and memberships. Rather than just a creator profile on the platform, it allows you to set up a website and have more control and ownership over your brand and audience.

Podia dashboard

Why I picked Podia

Podia is simple and easy to set up, but it takes you a step beyond purely membership sites like Patreon: it gives you a built-in course creation tool, product variety, and quite a toolset of marketing features. At the same time, it won’t overwhelm you with an unnecessarily complicated e-commerce stack.

Standout features

  • All-in-one website builder with custom domain support and sales pages
  • Unlimited products and bandwidth
  • Full online course creation functionality: video, audio, text, quizzes, drip-content schedule, etc.
  • Memberships and community features
  • Built-in blogging feature
  • Native SEO and marketing features, including simple automation (broadcasts, segment filters)
  • Bundling and upselling allow combining courses with other digital products 
  • Enables selling anywhere on social media, other websites, or through an affiliate program

Products you can sell

Structured online courses, digital downloads, membership subscriptions, and community access, one-on-one coaching sessions, webinars, and bundles (for example, a course + downloadable workbook + community access).

Integrations

Google Analytics, Stripe, PayPal, Zoom, YouTube Live, Mailchimp, Drip, Discord, Calendly, Facebook, Pinterest, Zapier, etc.

Podia dashboard

Pricing 

Starter Plan: Mover ($39 a month)

  • 5% transaction fee
  • Unlimited digital products, courses, memberships
  • Website builder with custom domain support
  • Email marketing tool

Best Value Plan: Shaker ($89 a month)

  • 0% transaction fee
  • Everything in Mover, plus:
  • Affiliate marketing functionality
  • Bundles and upsells
  • Embedded checkout
  • Help with migration
  • Priority support

Podia is a great solution for educators who want something more than Patreon, but don’t need the massive e-commerce infrastructure. However, it only targets the middle, since no free tier scares away many beginners, and simple tools won’t be enough for a bigger creator who might need an enterprise solution for scaling up.

Read more about the platform’s pros and cons in this Sellfy vs. Podia comparison.

4. Ko-fi: Best free Patreon alternative

Ko-fi is a platform for creators that is very similar to Patreon. It allows artists, designers, streamers, and freelancers to receive direct support from fans as donations and memberships, sell crafts and merch, and accept individual commissions. 

Ko-fi is newer, fresher, and definitely worth your attention as a more versatile Patreon replacement. It has its limitations, mostly due to lower visibility, but for artists who want both tip-jar support and product sales in one place without extortionate fees, Ko-fi is a great find.

Ko-fi dashboard

Why I picked Ko-fi

Of course, each platform on this list takes commissions or monthly payments, yet what made me nominate Ko-fi as a free Patreon alternative is low fees (0-5%) on sales and memberships, and the possibility to accept tips and donations without any cuts at all. Ko-fi is more flexible and more affordable than Patreon, so I recommend checking it out, especially for novice creators.

Standout features

  • Versatile and user-friendly storefront + tip jar with one-time donations
  • Customizable membership tiers
  • Commissions functionality allows your fans to book your services for specific tasks
  • Embeds and widgets: you can place “Buy” or “Tip” buttons on your website or blog
  • Built-in blogging functionality
  • You own your supporter list and can export it
  • Direct messaging with supporters in-app

Ko-fi dashboard

Products you can sell

Digital downloads, recurring subscription tiers, physical products, commissions/custom services, + accept one-off tips.

Integrations

PayPal, Stripe, Twitch, YouTube, Discord, Google Analytics, WordPress, Zapier, Mailchimp, Google Sheets, Trello. 

Pricing 

Starter Plan: Contributor ($0 a month)

  • 5% service fee on shop sales, memberships, and commissions, 0% fees on tips
  • All key features: donations, memberships, shop, commissions
  • Blog and page customization

Best Value Plan: Gold ($12 a month)

  • 0% service fees on all payments
  • Everything from free, plus:
  • Higher upload limits
  • Custom branding
  • Advanced analytics
  • Priority support

Ko-fi is a lightweight and flexible alternative to Patreon for accepting tips, commissions, and selling merch on top of memberships – all with lower platform fees. It’s a great choice for a newbie who doesn’t have the budget for more advanced tools. However, it lacks Patreon’s discoverability, so you will have to rely on your social media to get new supporters.

By the way, here is how you can collect donations and tips with Sellfy.

5. FanCircles: Best Patreon alternative for musicians and bands

FanCircles is a London-based platform founded in 2015 specifically to address the difficulty of monetizing social media following for musicians. It gives a creator a branded mobile app, web platform, monetization tools (memberships, merch, music, tickets), and community features all wrapped in one. 

FanCircles dashboard

Why I picked FanCircles

FanCircles was designed as a music-centric alternative to Patreon, drawing inspiration from fan clubs and focusing not on selling content but instead on an engaged fanbase. In addition to subscriptions, it has a white-label app environment, music industry-specific tools, merch, tickets, new tracks streaming, and means for fostering personal relationships within the community of fans.

Standout features

  • Artist-branded web and mobile app (iOS and Android)
  • Inclusive community for all fans (free + paid tiers)
  • Tiered memberships and fan-club subscriptions with exclusive content for superfans
  • Integrated ticketing and merch sale tools
  • Music streaming and release control 
  • Plethora of engagement tools (push notifications, live streams, in-app messaging, forums, etc.)
  • Full branding control (domain, visual customization, fan environment)
  • Built-in fan data analytics (behavior, interactions, monetization, etc.)
  • Native notification and email marketing tool

FanCircles dashboard

Products you can sell

Memberships, digital releases (streaming and downloads), physical merch, concert tickets/access passes, live streams, fan-club chats, Q&As, freebies, and bundles (album + merch + membership).

Integrations

Shopify, Ticketmaster, PushPass, Apple Wallet, Google Wallet, Zapier, Make, n8n, etc.

Pricing 

Starter Plan: Standard ($44.99 per month)

  • 1,000 pass holders included
  • Unlimited redesigns
  • Country-level analytics
  • Email support

Best Value Plan: Pro ($89.99 per month)

  • 5,000 pass holders included
  • Everything from Standard, plus:
  • City-level analytics
  • API access
  • Click-to-sale tracking
  • Loyalty rewards segmentation

FanCircles is worth considering only if you are serious about a music career. It offers exceptional fan engagement and monetization tools beyond simple monthly support. It creates a fully-branded experience for fans and gives you complete mastery over fan data. However, it also takes a lot of time and effort to set up, personalize, and master.

Read more on how musicians can monetize their talent.

6. Buzzsprout: Best Patreon alternative for podcasters

Buzzsprout is an all-in-one podcast-hosting platform that handles editing, publishing, distribution, analytics, and monetization. When you publish an episode on Buzzsprout, it appears on any online podcast directories you choose to connect to (Spotify, Google Podcasts, Stitcher, Podchaser). You aren’t locked in one platform, which helps discoverability.

Buzzsprout dashboard

Why I picked Buzzsprout

Buzzsprout was created with podcasters in mind and removes the need to manage your show on one platform and use separate services for subscriptions and bonus content. This simplifies things and is more creator-friendly, but the tradeoff is higher service fees than in most other apps like Patreon.

Standout features

  • Unified solution for editing, hosting, distributing, and monetizing
  • Unlimited team members in one account
  • The dynamic content feature for adding and removing content lets you update old episodes with new content or ads
  • Premium RSS feeds are compatible with multiple podcast apps
  • Flexible subscription types (early access, premium episodes, back catalog, ad-free)
  • Magic Mastering audio enhancement tool for automated editing
  • Cohost AI for content suggestion
  • Customizable website and embeddable player
  • Built-in analytics to track subscriber data, listener behavior, conversion rate, etc.

Buzzsprout dashboard

Products you can sell

Regular donations, bonus content, early access, access to back catalog, ad-free version of your show, subscriber-only full podcast feed.

Integrations

Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, Spotify, Stitcher, Podchaser, Patreon, Podfan, Buy Me a Coffee, PayPal, Cash App, etc.

Pricing 

Although Buzzsprout offers a free tier, it is very limited and doesn’t provide monetization option apart from ads, sponsorships, affiliates, support links to other platforms like Patreon, Podfan, PayPal, etc.

Starter Plan: 4 hours ($19 a month)

  • 15% platform fee on every transaction
  • 1 podcast
  • Magic Mastering and Cohost AI as optional add-ons for $5 a month each
  • 4 hours of uploads per month
  • Podcast website
  • Monetization tools: Listener support, subscriptions, Buzzsprout Ads
  • Advanced stats
  • Listing in Podcast Directories
  • Unlimited team members
  • Podcast RSS feed
  • Custom embed players
  • Dynamic content

Best Value Plan: 15 hours ($39 a month)

  • 15% platform fee on every transaction
  • Magic Mastering and Cohost AI as optional add-ons for $10 a month each
  • Everything from the previous plan, plus:
  • 5 podcasts
  • 15 hours a month
  • Personalized artwork, statistics, and RSS feed for every podcast

For podcasters, Buzzsprout makes much more sense than Patreon, since it’s a specialized and integrated app that makes starting a podcast, distributing, and monetizing with many options easy. Having everything in one place is a huge advantage that compensates for limited community features, lack of merch, and higher fees.

While on the topic of podcasts, how about giving this treasure-trove of career info a listen?

7. Buy Me a Coffee: Best Patreon Alternative for streamers

Buy Me a Coffee is a lightweight creator monetization solution that is very similar to Ko-Fi in name and in function, but superior to Patreon in many ways. On it, you can create fully customizable membership tiers, accept one-time donations, and add additional perks for your supporters (for example, one-on-one coaching).

Buy me a coffee dashboard

Why I picked Buy Me a Coffee

Buy Me a Coffee is very intuitive and easy to set up, but what makes it even better than Patreon is its versatility. It combines spontaneous support (people can tip you once to thank you for a great stream), tiered membership, and a storefront. The commissions are much lower than on Patreon, which is important, since streamers’ “natural habitat” Twitch splits proceeds 50/50.

Standout features

  • Personalized page on a platform (social-media-like style)
  • Storefront with digital products and merch
  • One-click tips/donations (your fans can support you without having to create their own account)
  • “Extras” marketplace where you can sell short tutorials, wallpapers, overlays, etc.
  • Customizable tiered memberships with access to paywalled content
  • Built-in blog and messenger for engaging with supporters
  • Explore creators (social-media-like discoverability feature)
  • Fully customizable widgets and embeds for “Support me” or “Extras” buttons on your website or regular streaming page
  • Stream Alerts to display tips and support during livestreams on OBS or Twitch
  • Learning resources (FAQ, Help Center, live chat)

Buy me a coffee dashboard

Products you can sell

Digital products (presets, overlays, video clips, etc.), memberships, one-time donations, access to exclusive content (photos, posts, podcasts), Instagram close friends access, 1-on-1 calls, tickets for events, physical goods.

Integrations

Google Analytics, Twitter Shout-outs, Discord, WordPress, Zoom, Zapier, IFTTT.

Pricing 

The platform takes 5% fee on all transactions (including tips). They do not display ads or have a paid tier for their creators, + you pay standard payment processing fees to Stripe, PayPal, etc.

Buy Me a Coffee is an easy and risk-free way to earn support from your fans, supplementing your income from Twitch. It’s great for accepting tips, selling small digital items, merch, and membership perks. It lacks Patreon’s community and engagement features, but compensates with simplicity, flexibility, and lower fees.

8. Payhip: Best Patreon alternative for artists

Payhip is a simple e-commerce platform that allows selling digital art, courses, memberships, etc. As a website builder, it gives more functions and control over your content and style, but takes much more time and effort to set up. Still, among full storefront solutions, it’s on the leaner side and has a commission-based free tier.

Payhip dashboard

Why I picked Payhip

Many platforms on this list can be good Patreon alternatives for artists, depending on the artist’s in question needs and the style of growing audience. However, what sets Payhip apart in my eyes is licensing support, copyrighting tools (for example, PDF watermarks), and other little things that can be particularly handy for digital and traditional artists.

Standout features

  • E-commerce solution with a website builder
  • Option to connect your unique domain 
  • Possibility to add collaborators and collaboration products
  • Built-in blogging feature
  • Unlimited digital uploads with files up to 5GB
  • PDF stamping and license keys to set download limits
  • Membership tiers with access to paywalled content
  • Native course builder
  • Native marketing tools
  • Built-in analytics
  • Tax automation (including VAT)
  • Embedded checkout allows placing “Buy” buttons in your portfolio and on other sites

Payhip dashboard

Products you can sell

Digital downloads, courses, tiered membership with access to paywalled content, physical products, coaching sessions, and bundles.

Integrations

Stripe, PayPal, Zoom, Calendly, Bookvault, Google AdSense, WordPress, Shopify, Weebly, Wix, Squarespace, Zapier, etc.

Pricing 

Starter Plan: Free Forever

  • 5% platform fee on each transaction (+ standard payment processing fees from PayPal or Stripe)
  • All features
  • Unlimited products
  • Unlimited revenue

Best Value Plan: Pro ($99 a month)

  • No platform fees (PayPal/Stripe will charge their standard fees)
  • All features
  • Unlimited products
  • Unlimited revenue

Payhip is a good replacement for Patreon if you prioritize sales over tips. It still has membership functionality, aimed at safely distributing your artwork and selling tutorials, along with collateral like presets, brush packs, textures, work in progress, behind the scenes, etc. It’s affordable, has a solid selection of built-in features, but takes time and effort to master.

9. Fourthwall: Best Patreon alternative for filmmakers and video creators

Fourthwall is best known as a storefront and print-on-demand merch, and is rarely named among websites like Patreon. Nevertheless, it has tiered memberships, paywalled content, community features, merch, and a possibility of a fully branded website. 

Yet most importantly, hidden in the depths of the dashboard is a built-in video hosting system. By the way, Sellfy offers independent hosting too – and so do several platforms on this list. The lack of video hosting is one of the biggest gaps in Patreon’s services that isn’t discussed often enough.

Fourthwall dashboard

Why I picked Fourthwall

Fourthwall is one of the very few platforms that combine VOD hosting, membership monetization, and e-commerce in a single sleek dashboard. It allows uploading HD videos (up to 1080p), organizing them into collections, gating them behind membership tiers, and creating a branded, studio-like home for your creations.

Moreover, paywalled collections feature allows creating curated video libraries: membership-only series, director’s cuts, behind-the-scenes, master classes, etc., which is more consumable than Patreon’s chronological feed.

Standout features

  • Branded website with a custom domain instead of the creator’s profile page
  • Built-in video hosting eliminates the need for third-party apps
  • Tiered memberships with private RSS feeds
  • Supports tipping/donations
  • Print-on-demand for merch with a built-in design feature
  • Community and engagement tools (polls, updates, Discord access, members-only badges)
  • Built-in blogging and messaging features
  • Sales tools (promo codes, giveaway links, gift cards) and analytics
  • Custom iOS and Android mobile app

Fourthwall dashboard

Products you can sell

Digital downloads, tiered memberships, tips, access to paywalled content, physical products (including POD merch), gift cards, and bundles.

Integrations

Google Analytics, Mailchimp, Klaviyo, Laylo, YouTube, Twitch, X Shops, TikTok (Feed and Shop), Meta Ads, Instagram, Facebook, StreamElements, Spotify, Discord, Zapier, etc.

Pricing 

Starter Plan: Free

  • 5% fee on digital product sales  and memberships
  • 0% fee on donations
  • 5 GB limit on digital products
  • Up to 2 team members
  • Mix of platform-handled and your own products
  • Fully customizable branded website (logo, domain, layout)
  • Video, audio, and image hosting
  • Community engagement tools

Best Value Plan: Pro ($15 a month)

  • Everything from Free, plus:
  • Free .store domain
  • 0% fees on digital products
  • Up to 100 GB of digital product storage
  • Unlimited team members
  • $10 of free sample credit every month
  • Priority customer support
  • Quarterly 1:1 expert guidance calls

Fourthwall removes many limitations placed by Patreon and gives more freedom and options for filmmakers and video creators. The platform’s native video hosting, customizable membership tiers, donations, branded website, and built-in store give creators more ways to monetize their content.

Something still doesn’t click? Explore other great VOD platforms.

10. Gumroad: Best Patreon alternative for photographers

Gumroad is an e-commerce platform for creators focused on selling digital assets either on your own storefront or through the Discover marketplace. Just like Patreon, it has a membership feature and takes very similar commissions. Both platforms take a 10% cut of standard transactions and a 30% cut of “facilitated” purchases (through Marketplace for Gumroad and Apple App Store for Patreon). 

Gumroad dashboard

However, if Gumroad cuts an additional $0.50 per transaction for processing, Patreon is a bit more complicated, with various fees depending on location and payment method. So, Gumroad is a little more predictable.

Why I picked Gumroad

Gumroad is a more flexible way to monetize your work as a photographer than Patreon. It’s a hybrid of memberships and a digital storefront that allows selling one-off photos, premium access to your content, tutorials, and accepting commissions. At the same time, it’s very hassle-free, leaving you more energy to concentrate on the creative side of things.

Standout features

  • Tiered membership plus storefront, commissions, and tips
  • Pay-what-you-want pricing lets fans choose how much to pay
  • Commission-based model without monthly fees
  • Discover Marketplace for exposure to new customers
  • Collaborators can be added to the same dashboard
  • Native email marketing tools
  • Platform-assisted tax handling (including VAT/GST)
  • Built-in basic analytics (sales history, customer data, earnings tracking)
  • Affiliate program for promotion

Products you can sell

Memberships, courses, tutorials, commissions, downloadable digital products, bundles, and tips.

Integrations

Mailchimp, Google Ads, Gmail, Google Sheets, Discord, Slack, Circle, Latenode, Make.com. Most of the integrations are only possible through Zapier or API.

Pricing

Gumroad does not have monthly subscription fees, but instead operates on commissions:

  • 10% +$0.50 per transaction for all sales on direct links and your storefront
  • 30% per transaction when new customers find you through Gumroad Discover Marketplace

Gumroad is an easy way to start selling your art online: it’s flexible, lean, creator-friendly, and is more sales-oriented than Patreon. It removes the pressure to constantly create new content and takes care of marketing and taxes. On the flip side, the high fees don’t convert into new features, so one outgrows Gumroad very fast.

How to migrate from Patreon

Migration from any platform where you’ve amassed a loyal following feels scary, but it doesn’t necessarily mean starting from zero or even disrupting your income. With the right alternative, good planning, and transparency with your audience, you will be able to move without making a dent in your follower numbers or in your earnings.

Here are the major steps to take:

  1. Audit your existing Patreon page. List your tiers, prices, and delivery methods. Note any popular perks that depend on Patreon’s tools.
  2. Export your Patrons list with email addresses and billing info.
  3. Decide what to keep or change. This is your chance to restructure membership tiers, drop unpopular or overcomplicated perks, and adjust them to match the new platform’s offerings (livestreams, downloads, one-on-ones, etc.) Poll your fans, if you’re unsure.
  4. Build your new membership setup before you announce any changes. Prepare tier structure, content hub, any perks or galleries, and little niceties like welcome messages and gifts.
  5. Soft-launch for yourself. Create a test membership purchase, check how your content looks behind the paywall, verify downloads, links, etc. Make sure everything works. 
  6. Make an announcement. Give your patrons context (why you are moving: fees, better features?), when you’ll be shutting down your Patreon page, instructions on how to switch, and what to do so their rewards continue uninterrupted. Pin the announcement and send it in multiple formats (Patreon post, email, socials).
  7. Overlap platforms for 1 or 2 billing cycles. Keep Patreon running to give your fans time to migrate. Pause billing on Patreon if possible to avoid double-charging and build trust.
  8. Shut down your Patreon. Before that, make sure you’ve delivered all promised rewards or compensated with some other perks, double-checked email exports, saved your content archive, and reminded members one last time about the move.

Most platforms on this list support CSV import and have great documentation to help you through the move. Some (like Sellfy, Podia, or FanCircles) even offer migration assistance and onboarding, so you won’t feel lost.

As for the fans, as much as some people hate changes, they are usually very supportive when they know that more of their money goes to their favorite creator directly instead of the platform. Plus, they can be as excited as you are about new perks and formats.

Which Patreon alternative should you choose?

I think I’ve already convinced you that there is no single “best” Pateon replacement – only the best match for your content format, relationship with your audience, and chosen monetization style. Start from the key features you miss on Patreon and choose based on your priorities, workflow, and revenue model.

If you need a full e-commerce solution with transparent pricing and no hidden fees, you can’t go wrong with Sellfy. Everything from customizable subscriptions to branded merch to curated content collections is there to monetize your creative talents and give back to your fans. 

With Sellfy, you can collect donations via the Pay-what-you-want feature, grant access to paywalled content, or manage a fully autonomous branded store on your own terms – no compromises.

However, if you are very casual or just starting your creative career with little to no following, you might look for something with no monthly fees. Then Buy Me a Coffee, Ko-fi, or Gumroad could be right for you.

If you need specific functionality, you might choose FanCircles for their music-friendly monetization model, Buzzsprout for seamless podcast distribution, Substack for inbox-first newsletter delivery, or Fourthwall for native video hosting.

Remember, the best alternative depends entirely on how you earn money and how you connect with your fans. Find a platform to fit you; don’t force your creativity to fit the platform.

Aleksey is a Content Marketing Specialist at Sellfy. He loves using language and the power of words to make even the driest eCommerce topics fascinating. Using his degree in literary studies and passion for the latest trends, he creates well-researched and structured content to inspire other people and help them grow their eCommerce business.

Related topics